|

|
Strategies |
Citizen Networks to
Address Urban Poverty
Experiences of Urban Community Development Office, Thailand
Somsook Boonyabancha, UCDO, ACHR |
|
Part |
1.
Key Issues in Addressing Urban Poverty |
|
Part |
2
Experiences from UCDO Thailand |
|
Part |
The Forms and Functions of
Community Networking to Address Urban Poverty |
|
To start a network |
It is always rather simple to start a community
network, with a little understanding about urban poverty and its direction
of development by people themselves. A gathering of urban poor groups to
talk about common issues and common action almost always leads to
some form of collaboration and networking, and almost always leads
to further meetings, gathering and eventually to some communal
action.
Most networks start out being very loose in the beginning. Having regular
gatherings, people from different communities and different parts of the
country learn to understand each other’s situation and problems, as well
as each other’s character before getting into some forms of
organization. The form these organizations take usually only emerges out
of more concrete interactions, in the process of making decisions or
implementing common activities together.
Therefore, it is possible to encourage network formation by trying
to set the conditions of communal decision-making and communal project
implementation.
Since 1996, UCDO has collaborated with DANCED to
develop Urban Community Environment Activities (UCEA), using the
programme’s Environment Fund to allow community networks to make
decisions and to implement community environmental improvement projects in
a given constituency, with advice from other local actors. The conditions
of the program have brought together community groups to work as stronger
community network in making decisions, and in promoting, implementing and
managing all the development activities involved in any community project
of the network. Therefore, each community which is linked to the network
has direct access to the wealth of knowledge and experiences from several
other community groups and has the chance to benefit from their
development activities at the same time. In this way, all work and all
successful processes in any particular community becomes learning source
for the whole network. Also, when problems emerge, the network can become
a joint mechanism to deal with problem of the members as well.
3.2 Diverse Types of Urban
Poor Community Networks
There are different types of community
networking. The basic idea behind a network should be how to create
linkages in ways that the urban poor communities control as much as
possible. The idea of community networking is not a new one, but the forms
of community networks which are clearly controlled and clearly understood
by the communities themselves are not too common. Most conventional
community networks are led by outsiders, as part of a strategic process
that is organized and controlled by government organizations or other
outside organizations, for poor people.
Because of this history of outside control, it is
important that community networks be organized from the bottom-up - from
the smallest constituency and acting as the base to link with larger
constituencies. In Thailand, community networks begin by linking among
communities in the same district or the same city, as a basic network
formation, then link together at provincial, regional and national levels.
There are also community networks which link with each other around the
same common development issues, such as networks of communities located on
State Railway land, communities along canals, or communities linked by
shared enterprises or welfare activities. Each type of community network
provides a common platform for communities with common backgrounds or
interests to work together to attain their continuous development
objectives as well as to negotiate together, as a group, for related
structural or policy change.
3.3
Integrated Development Functions of Community Networks to address urban
poverty
Once communities organize themselves into
community networks, a larger community development mechanism begins to
emerge to deal with their development in a much deeper and much larger
scale, gradually linking to the causes of various poverty problems. Some
examples from the process in Thailand are summarized here :
3.3.1 Community network to address
land and housing problems
Most urban poor groups have serious land and
housing problems. Insecurity of land tenure and eviction problems prevent
the urban poor from accessing their basic rights and in settling their
lives in the city properly. Behind this situation, there are large,
structural problems of land distribution and income disparity which are
part of the present economic system. These structural problems are too
great, too difficult and too expensive for any single urban poor person or
even for any single poor community to resolve alone. This is the
structural point where a community network can play an important role in
resolving problems too big for individuals.
In Thailand, several types of community networks
are dealing in several different, interesting ways with problems of land
and housing development. Some of these networks are working to address
these problems in the following ways :
 | To deal with eviction problems :
Community networks can work together to share experiences in how to
negotiate in eviction situations, as well as to help negotiate
together as a network for more proper alternatives to eviction which
acceptable to the poor. Effective negotiation processes can help make
an unequal system become a little more reasonable, with more equitably
shared responsibilities on both sides of the table. Eviction without
sufficient responsibility being taken by those actors who profit from
eviction will cause urban poor problems much worse and more complex. |
 | To link communities with the same landlord
or communities affected by same development policy to work together
for better, clearer policies and alternatives : There are cases
where communities located on land under the same ownership (such as
community networks on State Railway Land, communities on canals,
communities under traffic bridges, etc.) link themselves together to
search for their own alternatives and to develop a more productive
negotiating status with landowners. Some of these networks have not
only slowed down unnecessary eviction problems but have worked
together with landowners to create better, clearer policies for slum
redevelopment. |
 | To work together within the same city for
action to achieve secure land and housing for all urban poor
communities : In the past, problems of insecure land and housing
have always been dealt with by people alone, or by poor communities
alone - in isolation. So it has been difficult to solve such
big problems, which require considerable effort and coordination to
attain a desirable solution for just one single case. With the
existence of community network, if communities can work together to
understand the city-wide aspects of land and housing and related land
and planning policies and can carve out a new position for themselves
within the urban formula through their coordination and negotiation
capacity. And it is interesting to find that many communities in many
of the networks have been able to resolve their land and housing
problems together - permanently. There have been examples in
Thailand where urban community networks have made city-wide community
surveys, have done research to understand the different status and
related factors involved, have made a plan what to do for all
communities in their network and have started their negotiations with
different agencies as a group. This new direction of
development is very important for future land and housing development
for the urban poor. |
 | To form network of Community Housing
Cooperatives : There is another community network which links
communities involved in new housing development activities or
resettlement to new locations. This kind of network can help member
communities to negotiate for some adjustments of related rules and
regulations as well as apply for tax exemptions, since urban poor
housing development should be supported by the state, and regarded as
a non-profit social housing development process. Moreover, the
Cooperatives Community Network has provided a platform for learning
and sharing of experiences and knowledge in implementing difficult,
formal housing development activities. |
3.3.2 Community Network to develop quality
Savings and Credit Activities as well as a community Joint Development
Fund
Community savings and credit activities comprise
an important basic development mechanism and become a community’s
financial resource base for self-managed poverty development by community
people. If savings and credit activities can be developed and linked with
external process properly, they become a link to other resources and a
builder of community capacity to strengthen and increase income earning
and create better job opportunities. It can also help urban poor groups
improve their financial status and back them up in negotiations with
market organizations to increase earning capacity. In Thailand, there have
been some interesting developments within community networks around these
aspects :
 | Community network to help develop quality
of savings and credit groups of member communities : Communities
have regular meetings to report on the situation of savings and credit
activities in a community. They share experiences and learn how to
work effectively, how to deal with non-repayment problems, how to work
on accounting, etc. Several networks also try to bring more groups in
the network by working together to set up new saving groups in their
area. There are also many cross-network learning and through exchanges
and exposure visits. |
 | Development of Network Fund : The
development of the Network Development Fund has become a link
and a financial support mechanism among community saving and credit
activities of network members. UCDO has recently begun making loans to
community networks to allow those networks to develop their own Network
Funds to give loans to member communities as well as to finance
community network activities. |
3.3.3 Community Network to develop Community
Enterprise Activities
One of the main reasons why people are poor in
the first place is because they are entrepreneurially scattered and
isolated, not organized in such a way as to compete with the larger and
more influential private enterprise sector, and so continue to earn very
little. In the communities, where the poor have many different kinds of
jobs, it is not easy to organize people with similar job together. This is
an area where a community network can be very effective, and the
experience in Thailand illustrates several interesting ways in which
community networks can help develop community enterprises :
 | Community Networks take subcontract
directly from the Bangkok Municipality : In 1999, a number of
community networks in Bangkok have been able to win several
subcontracts from the BMA worth approximately 30 million Baht (US$ 0.8
million). The subcontract projects have included production of 350,000
school uniforms, collection of garbage within communities and in small
lanes, repair of roads and sidewalks, clearing up canals and drainage
ditches. Community networks propose (or tender) for those projects and
organize those activities with skilled community members. The Handicraft
Network was also awarded a large contract to produce bronze
souvenirs for the Asian Games, last year in Bangkok. This new level of
community enterprise and subcontracting activities could only have
been reached with the community savings and credit activities and with
loans and support from UCDO. There is enormous potential for the
development of more diverse community enterprise activities by
community networks in future. |
 | Community networks plan for economic and
financial development for their urban poor members : As with
community enterprises, networks have also organised themselves around
planning for land acquisition, house building, income generation and
family financial planning. Through these networks, linkages with local
job opportunities and business sectors can be tapped in a more
systematic way. Community networks can act as important promoters to
raise the status of many kinds of jobs and can push for better income
and better working conditions for their members, using support from
stronger economic groups, the municipality and academicians in the
same constituencies. |
 | Networks of the same professions : In
the case of Thailand, networks have also been formed by people with
the same jobs, such as taxi driver cooperatives and community
handicraft cooperatives. These kinds of job-specific networks can link
together to promote certain policy changes for their particular
professions. |
3.3.4 Development of a
Community Welfare System by Community Networks
The development of a community safety net to deal
with the very poor and disadvantaged groups within urban poor communities,
as well as the development of a basic welfare system for urban poor groups
are very crucial. During 1999, UCDO has coordinated with the Social
Investment Fund to develop a community welfare system using the
community network as the central organization among member communities.
The process began with network meetings in which each community identified
their own particular welfare problems and described the needs of their own
community’s disadvantaged groups. Then each community conducted its own
survey to assist in concrete planning of welfare activities based on
present realities. After that, there was meeting to talk about the
concrete types of welfare activities could be undertaken - How to do it?
How to work? Who to work with? How to coordinate? How to budget? How to
organize into several kinds of welfare funds? What should be relationship
between the network and community and target group? As a result of this
process, most urban poor community networks in Thailand have now organized
their own welfare funds to support some of the following welfare
activities :
 | Scholarships for school fees and welfare
revolving fund loans to pay school fees for those who are able to
repay, with flexible terms of repayment |
 | Funds and some grants for elderly citizens in
need |
 | Funds for medicines and hospital fees in cases
of illness |
 | Grants to rehabilitate drug addicts |
 | Small revolving fund loans for income
generation activities for those very poor families |
3.3.5 Development of
Urban Community Environment Activities by Community Network and Local
Partnership Committees
Since 1996, UCDO has coordinated with DANCED
to organize Urban Community Environment Fund for urban community
environment projects organized by community organizations and community
networks. The program has been deliberately designed in such a way as
allows community groups to be the main implementators, with the close
support from and management by community networks. The plan now is to link
the network together through a process of problem identification, decision
making, cost-sharing, budget preparation, and project implementation in Local
Project Committees, implementation, maintenance, management etc. As a
result, about 200 projects have been implemented in the past 2 years.
These environmental improvement projects, which include community centres,
drainage, water supply, bridges and paved walkways, are much cheaper and
much faster in the implementation than most government projects. The most
important aspect of these projects is that they not only improve the
environment of poor settlements, but they help strengthen the network and
to build partnerships with local administrations.
|
|