face to face
Part 2

What actually happens when people go to visit other poor people ?

Exposures To a

sidewalk

 tin shack dump sewer
 

Several months back, Ivy Anthony, a community leader from a savings scheme in the Eastern Cape of South Africa, went on an exchange visit to another savings scheme in Kwa Zulu Natal. 

The idea was to get help from a stronger group and pick up some strategies for dealing with some repayment problems they’d been having in her area - an area which had gained the reputation of something of a problem child in the South African Homeless Federation.

In Kwa Zulu Natal, however, she encountered problems with repayment that were as bad - if not worse - than her group’s back home. There were other problems as well - one leader had made off with the week’s savings. Instead of enlightenment, she encountered mayhem, and found herself in the unexpected position of offering advice, even suggesting ways of getting the money back! A few days later, a newly confident Ivy returned to the Eastern Cape, with fresh energy to tackle their local problems. "I don’t know why everyone is making such a fuss about our repayment problems - they’re not as bad as I thought!"

Exchanges take many forms. 
Some are like wake-up calls, some are highly ritualized, others are big events. Some work like museum visits, others like comfy drop-in visits between old chums. 

Some exposures have events that are carefully planned, all worked out, and others fly by in a chaotic whirl. Some encourage reflection, some galvanize to immediate action. But one thing that is common to all - no matter what the protocol - and that is that afterwards, when people go back home, or when they see off their visitors, they are a little bit different

Something has happened to shake things up - something always happens.

Ivy didn’t get what she bargained for in Kwa Zulu Natal, but she did get something. And that something set her work back home a clear step ahead of where it had been before she left. 
It’s often like that with exposure, where going somewhere else - someplace very different - can work on a mind that has got stuck like a good healthy thwack!

This is especially so the first time out. 
After a while, of course, if you come a second time and a third, that sense of shock diminishes and you progress to other insights, to deeper levels of understanding and the life of an exchange relationship moves ahead. 

You progress from being shocked by something to understanding it, and from comparing that situation to your own to having ideas to improve it. 

Each place provides its own unique thwack, and it’s own say of aiming it, to help visitors open up room for the next, more important part, which is the learning.


In the following pages we take a brief look at a few examples of typical community to community exchanges supported  by ACHR's TAP programme and  Slum Dwellers International. 

 

 

Some experiences are like that. 
You can be told about it, you can be shown the pictures and have it explained to you over and over again, in the greatest of detail, and you can say "Yes, yes, I understand." 

But often times, it's not until you actually go there and see that thing yourself, and experience it with your own five senses that you really get it - that thwack.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Intro

sidewalk

 tin shack dump sewer

The stories and text come from innumerable documents, conversations, e-mail messages, videos, speeches and notes, and weaving them together involved the very far flung editorial collaboration of Sheela Patel, Diana Mitlin, Joel Bolnick and Thomas Kerr. 
Additional layout and photos for this Web version by Maurice Leonhardt

Home Page Face to Face News Activities

 

 

Home ] Up ] SIDEWALK ]

Send mail to Maurice Leonhardt    achr@loxinfo.co.th  with questions or comments about this web site.
Last modified: December 23, 2003